
Choosing a digital marketing agency on the Gold Coast: a seven-point scorecard
Published · By Jason Cavallaro
Compare Gold Coast digital marketing agencies using seven questions about proof, fees, account ownership, lead quality and the people who do the work.

Choose a Gold Coast digital marketing agency that can explain what it would do for your business, show relevant work and tell you how you’ll know whether it’s working. A local address can make meetings or filming easier. It tells you little about how the agency will handle your account, diagnose poor enquiries or hand everything back if you leave.
Use this scorecard with two or three agencies. For each item, give 0 if there’s no clear answer, 1 for a plausible answer without evidence and 2 if the agency backs it up with something you can inspect. It’s a comparison aid, not a ranking of agencies.
1. Relevant proof
Ask: “Can you show me a similar project and explain what changed?” Look for a comparable customer, budget or sales process. An agency might show how it reduced irrelevant roofing enquiries or helped a builder separate renovation prospects from custom-home prospects. Ask when the result was measured and whether the figure means a form submission, qualified prospect, booked job or revenue.
2. A recommendation for your business
Ask: “What would you do first, and what would you leave alone?” A credible answer names a service, audience and first test. A business with strong Google traffic and slow follow-up needs a different plan from one with no local visibility. Check the agency understands the areas you serve and the jobs you want more of.
3. Costs and commitments
Ask: “What do we pay you, what goes to the platforms, and what is extra?” Separate management, media, creative, development and software. Ask about GST, setup, notice and what happens if you pause. Check who supplies photography, approves copy and updates the website.
4. Ownership and access
Ask: “Who controls each account, and what do we keep?” Get the answer for Google Ads, Meta, analytics, the website, creative files and lead records. Ask for admin access where appropriate and a clear handover process. Google’s advertising third-party policy
5. Enquiry quality and reporting
Ask: “How do you tell whether calls and forms turned into worthwhile work?” Request a sample showing total enquiries, qualified leads and sales outcomes. The agency should explain which outcomes it can measure and where gaps remain. Google’s qualified and converted leads guidance
6. The handoff after the click
Ask: “What happens after someone enquires?” Find out who gets notified, who follows up and how your team flags wrong locations, unreachable contacts or off-scope jobs. A report should lead to a decision about the offer, creative, landing page or follow-up.
7. Who does the work
Ask: “Who will I speak to after I sign?” Find out who runs the account, who can troubleshoot tracking and how often you will review results. If you need local filming or site visits, confirm what is included rather than assuming it comes with a Gold Coast address.
If two agencies score similarly, choose the one that makes it easiest to verify what it will do, how your team will be involved and what you’ll own. Book an Elite Consult to put our answer to the same test.

