Why does AI recommend my competitor instead of my business?

Find out how to diagnose why competitors appear in AI recommendations, inspect the sources and strengthen the practical evidence buyers can find.

Jason Cavallaro smiling beside the title “Why AI picks your competitor”

Say you’re a shutter installer servicing the Gold Coast. You ask an AI assistant who can help with privacy on street-facing windows. It recommends a competitor you know well. You’ve installed shutters for that exact problem for years. So why them?

Start by opening the links in the answer. The competitor might have a case study explaining the privacy issue, what they fitted and which suburb they worked in. Your site might have ten photos of comparable work without a sentence explaining what you installed or why. You can’t infer who does better work from that answer. You can check which details the assistant could point to.

Check the fit before blaming rankings

Write down the exact question, location, platform and date. A prompt asking for a local plantation shutter installer differs from one asking who can solve night-time privacy in a street-facing room. The second gives the assistant a specific problem. Run the questions in separate sessions and look for patterns instead of treating one list as a leaderboard.

Did it recommend the competitor, cite their site for advice or repeat a directory listing? Follow the URLs and check whether they support the service, location or outcome described. If the answer gives no source for a claim, mark the reason unknown. A real citation still can’t tell you exactly why the system selected a provider.

Look for missing evidence

Name the service plainly and explain what it solves. Publish a comparable project and, with permission, its suburb or service area. Describe what the buyer needed and what you delivered. A review about a different service may build trust without answering this question. Keep service areas and contact details consistent and make it obvious how to enquire.

If competitor project pages repeatedly appear, inspect what useful questions they answer that yours don’t. If credible directories or industry sites are cited, check that their information about you is accurate. Aim for evidence that helps people assess you, not generic mentions.

Separate an observation from demand

One Australian Semrush sample included a ChatGPT question about choosing the best local marketing agency for a small business. This is a useful example of a selection question, not a Google People Also Ask result or evidence of how often Gold Coast residents ask it. Semrush estimates volume for grouped topics rather than giving an exact count for each wording. Semrush methodology

Google also says its generative search features don’t require special schema or new AI text files. Check that your pages are accessible, useful and backed by evidence. Google Search Central

Watch: How we assess AI visibility for dental practices

Jason shows how to review which dental practices appear in AI answers and check the sources behind those recommendations. This is a research walkthrough, not a client results case study.

Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

If the same competitor keeps appearing, identify what useful evidence they publish that you haven’t made easy to find. That’s a practical brief for your website team. Book an Elite Consult to compare the answers with what your site says.

Book your Elite Consult
Share this article